A Moment of Reflection, Renewal, and Invitation

Over the past few months, I have been deeply encouraged by the number of people from around the world who have reached out regarding IndependentSacramental.org. It has been humbling to hear how these resources have been helpful—to clergy, to those discerning vocation, and to those simply trying to understand the Independent Sacramental Movement more deeply.

Several individuals have even expressed interest in developing similar resource hubs for their own countries and regions. That is something I wholeheartedly encourage. If this movement is to grow in a healthy and life-giving way, it will not be through centralization, but through mutual support, shared wisdom, and a spirit of collaboration across communities.

At the same time, I want to be clear about something: while I am a member of a particular ISM community—and I do not hide that—the purpose of this site is not to direct people toward any one jurisdiction. It is not meant to function as a funnel or gatekeeping mechanism. Rather, it exists to serve the broader movement by offering resources that can support all who are engaged in sacramental ministry outside traditional structures. I welcome collaboration with jurisdictions, but always with the intention of strengthening the whole, not elevating one part over another.

A Brief Personal Note

I had originally hoped to publish two clergy interviews already this year. Unfortunately, due to illness, I lost about a month of productivity and had to cancel those opportunities. I am now working to regain momentum.

I know that many have expressed interest in clergy interviews, and I remain committed to that vision. With the upcoming Utrecht Summer School this summer, I am hopeful that I will have opportunities to connect with others in the movement and conduct interviews that will be meaningful and enriching for the wider ISM community.

An Invitation for Feedback

As I continue to rebuild momentum, I would genuinely value your input:

What kind of content would be most helpful to you on this site?

Some possibilities I have considered include:

• Clergy interviews and vocational stories

• Practical ministry resources

• Theological reflections on ISM identity

• Guidance for forming communities or jurisdictions

• Historical and canonical studies

• Ecumenical dialogue and relationships

But I would much rather hear from you. What would serve you, your ministry, or your context?

On Perception, Tension, and Misunderstanding

Recently, I came across a post in which a Roman Catholic expressed frustration—particularly in chaplaincy settings—about Old Catholics being perceived as misrepresenting themselves. While I do not deny that misrepresentation can happen in any context, I think this reaction reveals something deeper.

There is, at times, a perception that the Independent Sacramental Movement—and Old Catholic communities more broadly—pose a kind of threat.

But why?

It is not because of our size. We are small, often scattered, and lack the institutional resources of larger churches. In fact, in many parts of the world, the Roman Catholic Church is growing significantly. We are not competing on those terms.

And yet, there is something about the ISM that can feel disruptive.

Perhaps it is because we embody a different model of ministry—one that is:

• More flexible and adaptive

• Less centralized

• Often more immediately responsive to pastoral needs

• Willing to serve in spaces where others may not be present

We are often able to accompany people who feel unseen, unheard, or unable to fully participate elsewhere. Not because we are better—but because our size and structure allow us to move differently.

That difference can sometimes be misunderstood as competition.

Let me be clear: I have no desire to “poach” anyone from another church. That is not the spirit of this movement, nor should it be. At the same time, I am not going to turn anyone away who is seeking sacramental life, pastoral care, or a place to encounter Christ.

We are not called to compete—we are called to serve.

What We Offer

If there is something distinctive about the ISM, it may be this:

We offer presence without excessive barriers. We offer sacramental life in places where it may otherwise be inaccessible. We offer pastoral care that is often deeply personal and context-specific. We offer a willingness to stand at the margins—where Christ so often stands.

None of this should make us a threat.

If anything, it should make us partners.

Brothers and sisters in the same Body of Christ.

A Lenten Reflection

As we continue through this Lenten season, perhaps this is an opportunity for all of us—across jurisdictions, traditions, and movements—to reflect more deeply on who we are called to be. Not defensive. Not competitive. But conformed more fully to Jesus Christ, the Great High Priest.

May this be a season of purification—not only personally, but also within our communities and jurisdictions—so that all we do may more clearly reflect His love, His humility, and His mission.

Peace,

Ben