top of page
Search

Sanctifying the Ordinary: Priesthood, Authenticity, and the Independent Sacramental Movement

Nov 7
6 min read

My Sisters and Brothers in Jesus Christ,


It has been some time since I last wrote on this website. Over the past several months, I have been working to improve my health, making significant changes to my diet and exercise, and allowing myself time to recover. I must admit that the process has sometimes been frustrating. My mind is often filled with ideas, projects, and things I would like to accomplish, but my body does not always cooperate. I am learning, sometimes reluctantly, that there are seasons in life when we must slow down, recognize our limitations, and accept that we cannot accomplish everything we would like.


Last night, I had the opportunity to listen to a recent podcast featuring Bishop David Oliver Kling, whom many of us know from Sacramental Whine. The episode, Beyond Denominations: Tradition, Authenticity, and the Future of Independent Catholicism!, was a thoughtful conversation about the Independent Sacramental Movement, its history, and its future.


Bishop David is always a joy to listen to. I appreciate his honesty about our movement, his commitment to understanding the historical development of the Church, and his desire to live that tradition authentically within a community that remains welcoming and inclusive. I particularly appreciated his recognition that the movement is changing and that what may have been sufficient in the past will not necessarily sustain us in the future.


One observation especially caught my attention: the importance of personal authenticity in explaining why many people remain within the Independent Sacramental Movement. I believe there is something profound in that observation, and it caused me to reflect on my own life and ministry.


I was ordained a priest in the Roman Catholic Church. Although I eventually reached a point where I could no longer remain within that institution, I have never ceased understanding myself as a priest. My years of formation, prayer, theological study, and ministry shaped me in ways that cannot simply be set aside. Priesthood became woven into the fabric of my life. It influenced how I understand God, how I see the world, and how I relate to other people.

I cannot imagine simply declaring that I am no longer a priest. To do so would feel like denying something fundamental about who I have become.  Yet I also recognize that priesthood cannot be reduced to personal identity. It is not simply something I possess or a title I retain. It is a vocation that must continually find expression in prayer, service, and communion with others. The challenge is discovering what that vocation looks like when it no longer takes the familiar form of parish ministry.


I do not currently lead a traditional faith community. Nevertheless, there are important practices and relationships that continue to shape how I live my priesthood.


I belong to a small ecclesiastical jurisdiction where I seek to remain accountable within the apostolic tradition. I pray the Divine Office and celebrate the liturgy. These practices anchor my life in the worship and prayer of the Church, reminding me that priesthood is never simply an individual undertaking.


I also work a full-time secular job. Over the years, I have increasingly come to understand this aspect of my life through the example of the worker-priest movement. I do not see my secular employment as something entirely separate from my priestly vocation. Rather, it is one of the places where that vocation must be lived.


Each morning, before beginning my work, I offer a simple prayer asking God to help me reflect Christ's presence, action, and love in the world. I ask that my words and actions might communicate something of God's compassion to those I encounter throughout the day.


I wish I could say that I consistently accomplish this. I do not. There are days when I am impatient, distracted, frustrated, or simply too absorbed in my own concerns. Yet the prayer remains important because it reminds me of who I am called to be, even when I fall short.

Over time, I have developed relationships with people who have entrusted me with deeply personal aspects of their lives. They have shared their fears, hurts, disappointments, grief, joys, hopes, and anxieties. Some may never attend a liturgy that I celebrate or seek a sacrament from me. Some may not even think of our conversations as particularly religious.  Nevertheless, I regard what they share with me as sacred.


There is something profoundly sacramental about being invited into another person's life, particularly during moments of vulnerability. To listen without judgment, to offer compassion without seeking anything in return, and to accompany another person through uncertainty can become expressions of Christ's presence in the world.


This does not replace the sacramental life of the Church. Nor does it diminish the importance of gathered worship, ecclesial community, or the Eucharist. Rather, I believe these encounters should flow from the same sacramental vision that we celebrate in our liturgies. The Christ whom we encounter at the altar is the same Christ whom we are called to recognize and serve in our neighbors.


All of this brings me back to the Independent Sacramental Movement and the questions we must ask about our future. In many places, the consolidation of parishes and the changing structures of institutional Christianity have made the development of personal relationships between clergy and the people they serve more difficult. At the same time, our own movement faces significant challenges concerning community, formation, accountability, and the meaning of authentic ecclesial life.


I do not believe the answer is simply to celebrate our independence or to insist that personal authenticity is sufficient. Authenticity matters, but Christian authenticity must always lead us beyond ourselves. It must find expression in relationships, service, and a genuine commitment to the life and mission of the Church.


During the podcast, Bishop David recalled the important influence of a conservative Catholic priest who spent time with him and helped set him on a path of discovery. What strikes me about that story is the power of a personal encounter. A relationship with one priest helped shape the spiritual journey of another person.


Perhaps there is an important lesson here for all of us.  Most of us in the Independent Sacramental Movement will never preside over grand cathedrals or minister to congregations numbering in the thousands. We may never build large institutions, operate extensive ministries, or receive recognition from the wider Christian world.  But we can make a difference in the life of one person.  That person might be a colleague at work, someone we meet at a grocery store or gas station, a neighbor, a friend experiencing a difficult time, or even a stranger who needs someone willing to listen.


We do not always need a sanctuary, a pulpit, or an elaborate liturgical setting to witness to the love of Jesus Christ. Sometimes the most important ministry we offer takes place in the most ordinary circumstances of daily life.


And perhaps that is one of the gifts the Independent Sacramental Movement can offer the wider Church: a renewed appreciation for the sacredness of ordinary life and the possibility of living a sacramental vocation beyond conventional ecclesiastical structures.


We must never confuse this possibility with an excuse for isolation or a rejection of Christian community. The priesthood exists for the Church and for the world, not merely for the personal fulfillment of the priest. Our challenge is to discover how our ministries, however small or unconventional, can remain genuinely connected to the faith, worship, and communion of the historic Church.


The future of our movement may not depend on how many bishops we consecrate, how many jurisdictions we establish, or how successfully we reproduce the outward structures of larger churches. It may depend much more on whether we are forming people capable of making the presence of Christ known in the world around them.


We have the opportunity to sanctify the ordinary, to approach everyday relationships with a sacramental imagination, and to bear witness to the presence of Christ in a world that often struggles to recognize him.


Perhaps the future of our movement begins not with building something grand, but with being faithful in the small places where God has already placed us.  And perhaps that is where authentic priesthood has always begun.

Peace,

Rev. Ben

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Becoming More Sacramental

My sisters and brothers in Jesus Christ, I want to begin by apologizing for how long it has been since I last wrote for this website. This has been a difficult year for me, both personally and profess

 
 
 

Comments


Independent Sacramental

©2023 - 2026 by Independent Sacramental. 

Our Mission:
To serve the Independent Sacramental Movement by providing theological resources, formation materials, and opportunities for dialogue among clergy and laity.
We seek to honor the diversity of the ISM while encouraging unity in Christ, sacramental integrity, and faithful pastoral practice.

​

Scripture References:
Unless otherwise noted, all Scripture quotations are taken from the Revised Standard Version of the Bible (RSV), copyright © 1946, 1952, 1971 National Council of the Churches of Christ in the U.S.A., and used by permission. All rights reserved.

​

Permissions and Use:
Content on this website may be freely shared, quoted, or distributed for educational and pastoral use, provided that appropriate credit is given to independentsacramental.org and that materials are not reproduced or sold for commercial purposes.

​

Disclaimer:
This website is an educational and pastoral resource intended to promote understanding of the Independent Sacramental Movement. All opinions expressed reflect the perspectives of contributors and do not necessarily represent every jurisdiction or community within the movement.

​

​

bottom of page